The Pidyon Ha’ben

Joseph F. Dumond

Isa 6:9-12 And He said, Go, and tell this people, You hear indeed, but do not understand; and seeing you see, but do not know. Make the heart of this people fat, and make their ears heavy, and shut their eyes; lest they see with their eyes, and hear with their ears, and understand with their hearts, and turn back, and be healed. Then I said, Lord, how long? And He answered, Until the cities are wasted without inhabitant, and the houses without man, and the land laid waste, a desolation, and until Jehovah has moved men far away, and the desolation in the midst of the land is great.
Published: Jan 24, 2025

Newsletter 5860-049
The 1st Year of the 5th Sabbatical Cycle
The 29th year of the 120th Jubilee Cycle
The 24th day of the 12th month 5860 years after the creation of Adam
The 5th Sabbatical Cycle after the 119th Jubilee Cycle
The Sabbatical Cycle of the Red Heifer, Famine, Captivity & The 2 Witnesses

January 25, 2025

Shabbat Shalom to the Royal Family of Yehovah, 

Two weeks ago, we posted an article titled “Ben Ha Arbayim or Between the Evenings—When is it?” Last week, I posted After Two Days is Passover Counting the Six Days of John, which I have done in order to help those willing to search discover the truth about when to eat the Passover meal. It is eaten at the end of the 14th and at the beginning of the 15th. The next question people ask is then what was the Last Super if it was not a Passover meal? And that is what I will show you this week.

Then I received this email and people are beginning to think about this and understand.

Hello Joseph. Things have been going crazy lately and I am just now reading your last Sighted Moon post. Great question, if Yeshua is the sacrificial Lamb of God, He would have been crucified before Passover started (that evening) the Lamb was sacrificed for the Passover. A major part of Passover is the Sedar, eaten as an acknowledgement of the Angel of Death passing over the homes with the sacrificial blood on the door post. So, Yeshua could not have participated in the Sedar if His blood was used for atonement of our sins. Not to waste your time but this is a critical data point that had been misunderstood for a very long time.
Pop Quiz: Was Peter the first Pope of the Catholic Church?
JK

I received this great endorsement from Lucinda Robinson on FaceBook about The Stones Cry Out Part 1. I hope you all will write favourable comments like this on Amazon so others can see it. It is one way you can help spread the word by encouraging others to get the books.

This book by Joseph Dumond will bring unity. There are many true believers deceived on the subject of reckoning the beginning of a Scriptural year. This book examines each calendar and its history and compares them to exactly what Scripture reveals. Whether you use the equinox, Zadok, Jubilees, Hillel, Julian, Enoch, or other calendar, you must read this book to get the full picture and history of each one. This book HAD to be written. Such detail! Such shutting down of arguments by FACTS! I urge every sabbath and feast keeper to read this book!

You can get your Free PDF copy here. https://sightedmoon.com/the-stones-cry-out-lp/

I would like to remind you all to go to your spam box and search for any newsletter from sightedmoon.com. We generally send them out on Thursdays at midnight, Eastern Time zone time. Check your spam to see if our emails are there, and then move them to your inbox so they are no longer considered spam. You may have to do this to two or three emails to train your server to put them in the right box.

The National Religious Broadcasters Convention is approaching February 24-27, 2025. We are now contacting many of the media outlets that will be there, asking them to interview us so we can share our message about the Jubilee Cycles. I ask you all to pray that Yehovah will open this door wide for us and that we can reach many through this event. At the NRB we will be connecting with FrontGate Media who have been doing some of our past advertising over the past two years and created two of our recent videos. They are front and center at the NRB and can introduce us to those we need to speak to. We are talking to them about an advertising campaign to get me on several podcasts and radio shows to explain our message. This starting cost is $5000 for two months and my goal is to do this for the next twelve months. It will cost $30,000 to hire FrontGate to market me and our message to as many megaphones as we can reach. I am not going to be able to do this on my own. I need your help. As you read this week’s newsletter, you will see why we must speak out now while we can. If you do not support this work, may I ask you to consider helping us now? We are running out of time. I am going to go forward on this. I am asking for your help. You can watch this video and become a supporter at this link. https://sightedmoon.com/supporters-lp/

Through the NRB show, I have contacted another promoter (IAMPRONLINE) and am talking with them about how to promote our message and get it in front of the TV and Radio media. And there could be other promoters I have to meet. Again, I ask for your prayers and that Yehovah opens the door He wants us to go through. However, each of these companies wants to be paid for this service. Again, we need divine intervention, and that comes from all of us asking Yehovah to open the door and to send sponsors.

Our small team is leaving for Israel this week. I want to thank you all for your prayers for our safety. As a result of your prayers, Yehovah inspired Israel and Hamas to have a truce and to exchange hostages for prisoners. So we expect now to have no drones or missiles shot at us from the Houthi, Hezbollah, or Hamas while we search out in the fields for the Barley during our time there. Thank you, Yehovah. But now, in exchange for the hostages, murderers and hardened criminals will be and are being released back into East Jerusalem, where we will be going. They are also being set free in Samaria and Gaza. These are those terrorists who stabbed and murdered innocent people and were caught. These are those lone wolfs who often act alone at bus stops, gas stations or cafes. So, I again implore your prayers for our protection and safety during our time there as we search on your behalf to determine if the barley is Aviv or if we are to add an Adar Bet. Many of you are watching and relying on this information so that you can keep your Feasts when Yehovah said to keep them. In this matter, I will also need your financial support. We share this information for free, but paying for airfare, hotel, car rental, and food costs money. I am asking those of you who are not yet supporting this work to please help by giving as little as $25 a month. Those who do support this work have access to all our PDFs and audiobooks from the time you begin to help—all of them. https://sightedmoon.com/supporters-lp/

Once I return from Israel, I will have to turn around and leave for Texas and the NRB event. I will be driving there, which is about a 20-hour drive. We are working on a speaking tour to the Philippines in April. And we are reaching out to the people of Japan, Singapore, Hongkong and Thailand. If you are interested in having me come and present this end-time information to your group and to your country, then please reach out to your Pastor and to your group and consider inviting me to your assembly. It is time. We are in the gun lap and once you see it, you too will see our urgency. Please reach out and let me know. Thank you for your help.

Also this week, Baby its cold outside. There were snow blizzards in Florida, and along the Louisiana coast, and at the same time, another wildfire broke out in California. Which god is Yehovah mocking now? Make sure you read the section on patterns and pay attention to the information about the stock markets in relationship to 2020, the middle of this 120th Jubilee cycle.

Join Our Sabbath Meetings

Join Our Sabbath Meetings

There are many people in need of fellowship and who are sitting at home on the Sabbath with no one to talk to or debate with. I want to encourage all of you to join us on Shabbat, and to invite others to come and join us as well. If the time is not convenient then you can listen to the teaching and the midrash after on our YouTube channel.

What are we doing and why do we teach this way?

We are going to discuss both sides of an issue and then let you choose. It is the work of the Ruach (Spirit) to direct and to teach you.

The medieval commentator Rashi wrote that the Hebrew word for wrestle (avek) implies that Jacob was “tied”, for the same word is used to describe knotted fringes in a Jewish prayer shawl, the tzitzityot. Rashi says, “thus is the manner of two people who struggle to overthrow each other, that one embraces the other and knots him with his arms”.

Our intellectual wrestling has been replaced by a different kind of struggle. We are wrestling with Yehovah as we grapple with His Word. It is an intimate act, symbolizing a relationship in which Yehovah and you and I are bound together. My wrestling is a struggle to discover what Yehovah expects of us, and we are “tied” to the One who assists us in that struggle.

Today, many say Israel means “Champion of God”, or better — the “Wrestler of God”.

Our Torah sessions each Shabbat teaches you and encourages you to constantly challenge, question, argue against, as well as view alternative views and explanations of the Word. In other words, we are to “wrestle with the Word” to get to the truth. Jews worldwide believe that you need to wrestle with the Word and constantly challenge Dogma, Theology, and views or else you will never get to the Truth.

We are not like most churches where “The preacher talks and everyone listens.” We encourage everyone to participate, to question and to contribute what they know on the subject being discussed. We want you to be a champion wrestler of the Word of Yehovah. We want you to wear the title of Israel, knowing that you not only know but are capable of explaining why you know the Torah to be true with logic and facts.

We have a few rules though. Let others talk and listen. There is no discussion about UFO’s, Nephilim, Vaccines or conspiracy-type subjects. We have people from around the world with different world views. Not everyone cares who is the President of any particular country. Treat each other with respect as fellow wrestlers of the word. Some of our subjects are hard to understand and require you to be mature and if you do not know, then listen to gain knowledge and understanding and hopefully wisdom. The very things you are commanded to ask Yehovah for and He gives to those who ask.

Jas 1:5  But if any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask of God, who gives to all liberally and with no reproach, and it shall be given to him.

We hope you can invite those who want to keep Torah to come and join us by hitting the link below. It is almost like a Torah teaching fellowship talk show with people from around the world taking part and sharing their insights and understandings.

We start off with some music and then some prayers and it’s as though you were sitting around the kitchen back in Newfoundland having a cup of coffee and all of us enjoying each other’s company. I hope you will grace us with your company someday.

Sabbath services begin at 12:30 PM EDT where we will be doing prayers, songs and teaching from this hour.

Shabbat midrash will begin at about 1:15 pm Eastern.

We look forward to you joining our family and getting to know us as we get to know you.

Joseph Dumond is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting.
Topic: Joseph Dumond’s Personal Meeting Room

Join Zoom Meeting

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/3505855877

Meeting ID: 350 585 5877
One tap mobile
+13017158592,,3505855877# US (Germantown)
+13126266799,,3505855877# US (Chicago)

Dial by your location
+1 301 715 8592 US (Germantown)
+1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago)
+1 346 248 7799 US (Houston)
+1 669 900 6833 US (San Jose)
+1 929 436 2866 US (New York)
+1 253 215 8782 US (Tacoma)

Meeting ID: 350 585 5877
Find your local number: https://us02web.zoom.us/u/kctjNqPYv0


The Perpetual Calendar

The Perpetual Calendar

We have available from our website a calendar you can use to keep track of the days of the month based on when the barley is ripe and when the moon is sighted. All you have to do is download it. https://sightedmoon.com/perpetual-calendar/

With the new year about to begin, you can learn about the calendar as you record it. This is a great tool to have and it is free to anyone who wants it.

21 Comments

  1. Thank you for sharing this important topic I asked this question to a lot of people in the past that”If Yeshua is the Passover lamb than hoe can He eat the Passover the night before?” But no one seemed to be bothered with this. Thank you for confirming it that I am not the only one.

    Kornelis

    Reply
  2. Matthew 26v17-18
    Now on the first day of the Feast of Unleavened Bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying to Him, “Where do You want us to prepare for You to eat the Passover?”
    18 And He said, “Go into the city to a certain man, and say to him, ‘The Teacher says, “My time is at hand; I will keep the Passover at your house with My disciples.

    Reply
  3. Joe
    Why stir up such bs ? The Gospel already answers all questions now you go and throw this twist on it.

    The last supper was the start of the 14th day and he died between the evening of 14th and the 15th. That’s way they broke the legs of the two criminals as a Shabbat was starting ie Matzah day 1. Stop all this commentary from who knows where! Are you trying to sell another book? What’s the point of muddying the pure Gospel of our Lord???

    Reply
    • On the contrary Robert this is not BS. We have posted about the between the evenings explaining that on our article, https://sightedmoon.com/ben-ha-arbayim-or-between-the-evenings-when-is-it-2/
      We followed that article up with our article about how to count the 6 days of John, https://sightedmoon.com/after-two-days-is-passover-counting-the-six-days-of-john/ In this article we showed you how Yehshua said just before he sent the apostles to prepare the room in the verse you quote. Yehshua said there was still TWO Days until the Passover. And yet that night they ate the Last Super Meal. So was Yehshua lying or do many of you jus tnot understand when Passover is to be kept.
      He is the same yesterday today and forever. So He did not change when the Passover meal was to be eaten. It is eaten after the Lamb is killed at the end of the 14th. Yehshua was that Passover Lamb and He was killed at the end of the 14th just as they were. After He was killed then all of Judah ate the Passover meal at the start of the 15th.
      And this is why we post these newsletters year after year, so the brethren have time to study them out and learn the truth rather than continue to follow false teachings. It is not BS. But it is done in love. Dont just dig in your heals. Study to show yourself approved by Yehovah. The Sabath and Holy Days are tests. Are you going to pass this test?

      Reply
      • Ok Joe. What about the other gospels that say he kept the Passover? Matthew Mark Luke? Why can’t you address this discrepancy?

        Your other articles mean nothing is there are contradictory verses unanswered and not quoted in the same teaching.

        Stick the Scriptures otherwise this teaching is pointless and is only going to further divide the Church. Is that your agenda? Only Joe can ever be the authority?

        Are you passing the test? Joey? Who’s holding you accountable? Only you can be accurate? My article says it so it’s true……bs

        Reply
        • This teaching is pointless and it’s heresy. To support rabbinical traditions and customs such as Fast of the Firstborn and moving the Passover to the 1st day of Unleavened bread creates confusion from the simplicity of scripture and we are not suppose to add or take away from it.

          The Fast of the Firstborn is NOT referenced in Torah. The only fast day as a required commandment in Torah is the feast day of Day of Atonement. Period.

          This tradition stems from the Talmud which we should avoid like the plague. The Talmud is the backbone of Judaism and Jewish mysticism (kabbalah). Kabbalah and mysticism is dark esoteric arts. Again- anything related to the Talmud is based on the esoteric and there is nothing holy about it. If people don’t believe me just check out Chabad.org which is the organization that promotes Judaism and they don’t even hide the fact that the Talmud is founded on Jewish mysticism.

          Matthew 15:6-9
          6 And honour not his father or his mother, he shall be free. Thus have ye made the commandment of God of none effect by your tradition. 7 Ye hypocrites, well did Esaias prophesy of you, saying,
          8 This people draweth nigh unto me with their mouth, and honoureth me with their lips; but their heart is far from me. 9 But in vain they do worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.

          Reply
        • Shalom:

          I am submitting the following in response to matter raised by Robert in last week’s newsletter “What about the other gospels that say he kept the Passover? Matthew Mark Luke? Why can’t you address this discrepancy?, and echoed by J.W. Brakebill Jr., etc.

          The Passover Discrepancy in the Gospels–Matthew, Mark and Luke Being Different from John

          Shabbat, 13/01-02, 5860/5861
          (Saturday, February 1, 2025)

          What about the other gospels that say he kept the Passover? Matthew Mark Luke? Why can’t you address this discrepancy? (Robert – 24/01/2025 at 1:29 pm)
          https://sightedmoon.com/the-pidyon-haben/

          Matthew 26:17-20 (NKJV)
          Jesus Celebrates Passover with His Disciples
          17 Now on the first day of the Feast of the Unleavened Bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying to Him, “Where do You want us to prepare for You to eat the Passover?”
          18 And He said, “Go into the city to a certain man, and say to him, ‘The Teacher says, “My time is at hand; I will keep the Passover at your house with My disciples.” ’ ”
          19 So the disciples did as Jesus had directed them; and they prepared the Passover.
          20 When evening had come, He sat down with the twelve.

          Mark 14:12-17 (NKJV)
          Jesus Celebrates the Passover with His Disciples
          12 Now on the first day of Unleavened Bread, when they [d]killed the Passover lamb, His disciples said to Him, “Where do You want us to go and prepare, that You may eat the Passover?”
          13 And He sent out two of His disciples and said to them, “Go into the city, and a man will meet you carrying a pitcher of water; follow him. 14 Wherever he goes in, say to the master of the house, ‘The Teacher says, “Where is the guest room in which I may eat the Passover with My disciples?” ’15 Then he will show you a large upper room, furnished and prepared; there make ready for us.”
          16 So His disciples went out, and came into the city, and found it just as He had said to them; and they prepared the Passover.
          17 In the evening He came with the twelve.
          Footnote d. Mark 14:12 sacrificed

          Luke 22:7-16 (NKJV)
          Jesus and His Disciples Prepare the Passover
          7 Then came the Day of Unleavened Bread, when the Passover must be [a]killed. 8 And He sent Peter and John, saying, “Go and prepare the Passover for us, that we may eat.”
          9 So they said to Him, “Where do You want us to prepare?”
          10 And He said to them, “Behold, when you have entered the city, a man will meet you carrying a pitcher of water; follow him into the house which he enters.11 Then you shall say to the master of the house, ‘The Teacher says to you, “Where is the guest room where I may eat the Passover with My disciples?” ’12 Then he will show you a large, furnished upper room; there make ready.”
          13 So they went and found it just as He had said to them, and they prepared the Passover.
          Jesus Institutes the Lord’s Supper
          14 When the hour had come, He sat down, and the [b]twelve apostles with Him. 15 Then He said to them, “With fervent desire I have desired to eat this Passover with you before I suffer;16 for I say to you, I will no longer eat of ituntil it is fulfilled in the kingdom of God.”
          Footnotes
          a. Luke 22:7 Sacrificed
          b. Luke 22:14 NU omits twelve

          1: The above accounts are not in line with the Torah and other passages in the Old Testament. The Old Testament passages indicate that the Passover sacrifice should take place on the 14th, not on the First Day of Unleavened Bread as per Mark 14:12 and Luke 22:7. See Exodus 12:6; Leviticus 23:5; Numbers 9:3; Numbers 28:16; Joshua 5:10; 2 Chronicles 35:1; Ezekiel 45:21.

          2: Even when done in the second month, it was still to be on the 14th: Numbers 9:11; 2 Chronicles 30:15.

          3: If taken as is, the above passages would have Yeshua’s last meal with his disciples before His crucifixion being at the end of the 15th as per Matthew26:20 and Mark 14:17, in which case, he would have missed the prescribed time if he were to have died as the Passover Lamb. In Matthew 26:20, the phrase “When evening had come …”, indicates that Yeshua’s initial conversation with his disciples about the Passover was not in the evening, as evening had not yet come. Therefore, if this was the First Day of Unleavened Bread (the 15th of the 1st), the meal would have had to be at the end of the day, since the conversation would have taken place before evening, as evening had not yet come. If Yeshua ate the Passover as indicated by Matthew, Mark, and Luke, on what basis would this not have been a contravention of Torah, and of his own words in Matthew 5:17-20 “I have not come to abolish the law”?

          4: Another point that suggests that this last meal was not the Passover is the use of the Greek word artos which is indicative of bread with leaven. The Passover, however, was to be eaten with Unleavened Bread: “Then they shall eat the flesh on that night; roasted in fire, with unleavened bread and with bitter herbs they shall eat it” (Exodus 12:8, NKJV). See also Deuteronomy 16:3-4.

          5: In contrast to the accounts found in Matthew, Mark, and Luke above, the Gospel of John is in compliance with the various Old Testament Passages.

          6: John identifies Yeshua’s last meal before His crucifixion as being before the Passover: “Now before the Feast of the Passover …” (John 13:1, NKJV).

          7: John also identifies that the trial of Yeshua, which was after this last meal with his disciples, as being before the Passover: “Then they led Jesus from Caiaphas to the Praetorium, and it was early morning. But they themselves did not go into the Praetorium, lest they should be defiled, but that they might eat the Passover.” See also John 18:39.

          8: John 19:14 identifies the day of Yeshua’s crucifixion (which according to John, was after the last meal) as the “Preparation Day of the Passover”: “Now it was the Preparation Day of the Passover, and about the sixth hour. And he said to the Jews, “Behold your King!”

          9: John 19:31 identifies the events of the crucifixion as being before a “Sabbath”, a likely reference to the First Day of Unleavened Bread. If both the account of john and the account of Matthew, Mark, and Luke are different, both are likely not correct.

          10: Additionally, it is quite noteworthy That Paul in his reinstitutionalization of the commemoration of the “last supper of Yeshua before his death” in 1 Corinthians 11:17-34 makes absolutely no reference to it as the Passover. This is similar to the account in John 13, where the meal is not referred to as the Passover.

          11: In contrast, in 1 Corinthians 5:7, Paul refers to Yeshua (Christ) as “our Passover”. If the Last Supper were the Passover, or even synonymous with it, why would Paul not have referred to it thus in 1 Corinthians 11, similar to his reference to Yeshua as “our Passover” in 1 Corinthians 5:7? And why did John not have referred to the meal as the Passover in chapter 13, a reference he used later in 18:28, 39; and 19:14 and 19:31?

          12: Other points for consideration may include the fact that John was not only an eye witness to very notable activities in Yeshua’s ministry, but even more significant, is the fact that he was very likely part of his inner circle, whereas the authors of the other Gospels were not.

          13: While not claiming to have all the answers to the above issue at this moment in time, it is strongly possible that the references in Mathew 26 and Luke 21, noted above, could be mere regurgitations from the Gospel of Mark, since it is widely accepted that both Matthew and Luke used Mark as a source in compiling their own Gospel records; hence all three being known as the synoptic gospels, and being different from the account of John in respects as is being addressed here. Along these lines, we find in the Introduction of the Gospel of Luke in the New American Bible, 2010 Revised Edition (the sixth paragraph), the following:
          “Among the likely sources for the composition of this gospel (Lk1:3) were the gospel of Mark …”
          “Some hold that Luke used Mark only as a complementary source for rounding out the material he took from other traditions.”

          14: Similarly, the introduction of Matthew (paragraphs 20-22) states,
          “The ancient tradition that the author was the disciple and apostle of Yeshua named Matthew (see Mt10:3) is untenable because the gospel is based, in large part, on the Gospel according to Mark (almost all the verses of that gospel is utilized in this) …”
          “The unknown author … drew not only upon the Gospel according to Mark, but upon a large body of material (principally, sayings of Yeshua) … that corresponds, sometimes exactly, to material found also in the Gospel according to Luke.”

          15: In conclusion, the following questions are pertinent to the above issue and are submitted for possible response:
          • If the account found in Matthew, Mark and Luke is correct, how would that not have been a contravention of Torah and his own words as per Matthew 5:17-20 “I have not come to abolish the Law”, since Yeshua would have had to change the time of Passover as was commanded in the Torah?
          • Since the account of John (who was an eye witness) and account found in Matthew, Mark, and Luke (who were likely not eye witnesses) are different, what determines that the account found in Matthew, Mark, and Luke should be accepted over the account found in John?

          Shalom

          Reply
  4. Now on the first day of the Feast of Unleavened Bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying to Him, “Where do You want us to prepare for You to eat the Passover?”
    18 And He said, “Go into the city to a certain man, and say to him, ‘The Teacher says, “My time is at hand; I will keep the Passover at your house with My disciples.

    Reply
    • You will always win this petty arguments bc it’s your website with your administration handling the content.

      In the real world when you are responsible for dividing an unified group you will reap immediate consequences

      That’s why I told you long ago you are not a leader of the elect. You’re just a guy with a website. The way you treat brothers and sisters over the years is despicable.

      Maybe that’s why you’re divorced?

      Are your kids around?

      Hey Joe, this is serious stuff. Maybe you should rethink how treat people in the future?

      Must you always be right?

      Let’s face it….you’re quite wrong.

      You predicted war in USA and the EU for 2020

      Wrong

      You said the tribes would be eaten up figuratively speaking

      Wrong

      Now we are in captivity years….

      Where’s the captivity?

      You were wrong about Trump

      You were wrong about a lot things

      This is just a website

      The real kingdom of God is inside his people and you divide them with your arrogance.

      What you dish out may it come back to you Joey.

      Maybe you don’t have a grasp on things Joey…

      We’ll see

      Reply
      • That is very sad Robert that you have such anger in your life, I don’t agree with Joseph 100% of the time, but he has well over 95% of the time got a good grasp on what the bible teaches. One thing we have to remember is that the word of YHWH is never wrong, BUT the translation of his word can be wrong. having the bible translated from its original language can bring with it errors. I have a podcast I listened to once by Rabbi Brian Stephens, called the Passover problems. the speech was given when Tom Bradford from Torah Class ministries was being ordained. One of the errors that Rabbi Stephens spoke about is one that you have mentioned above, in Mathew, Mark and Luke’s Gospels.

        In Matt 26:2 Ye know that after two days is the feast of the Passover, and the Son of man is betrayed to be crucified.

        Now in the Mishnah there is a debate about the 14th day of Nissan, whether one can do work or not. The school of Hillel says you can until noon. The school of Shammai says you can’t at all. All preparation for Passover and unleavened bread has to be made on the 13th day of Nissan before sundown. And Yeshua and his disciple were from where? Galilee and it says in the mishna that the Galilean’s followed the teachings of Shammai.

        Matt 26:17 Now the first day of the feast of unleavened bread the disciples came to Jesus, saying unto him, Where wilt thou that we prepare for thee to eat the passover?

        Now we all know this is wrong, this is not what the disciples said, because you cannot have unleavened bread before the Passover. so what is wrong? well the Rabbi points out that in the original language was in something called dative case(if that is how is spelled) which meant that it was for the “sake of” or “for the purpose of” the first day of unleavened bread. the speech he gives is about 50 mins and has other Passover problems, which Atheists use against the bible. Hope this helps.

        Reply
  5. Mark 14v12 and Luke 22v7 both say on the day the Passover lamb was killed the disciples asked the Lord where they should have the meal.

    Why are you going against the scriptures? What’s your agenda? Can only you be right? Everyone else is just dumb???

    Reply
  6. Thank you Joseph: Many of our Jewish brethren practice Pidyon Ha”ben – five shekels given in memory of the firstborn spared in the tenth plague. Also, the Fast of the Firstborn is still observed the day before the Passover meal (the 14th before the 15th of Unleavened Bread begins) I’ve read the Galileans observed customs and traditions not kept in Judea. Of course I can’t remember my source. Peter

    Reply
  7. Good teaching, Joseph. But I still have a question. If we were to eat the Passover Lamb which symbolizes our messiah, on the 15th; then should we not eat the bread and wine on the 15th as that now symbolizes our messiah? It is clear that Jesus exchanged the symbol of the lamb to the symbols of bread and wine; but was He also telling us to change the date to the 14th as many have taught?

    Reply
  8. Joseph and Readers
    Why did Hashem tell Moses to tell the Israelites, regarding the animals for the Passover table, “.. take them from the sheep or the goats” Exodus Chapter 12. Banebdjed was the Egyptian ram god – read sheep, while the Egyptian god Djedet is shown with the head of a goat. Eat either and you’d be defiling two of the main Egyptian dieties, with Hashem’s chosen spitting in Pharaoh’s face. It had nothing to do with Jesus as the Lamb of God. Sorry. Peter

    Reply
  9. Shalom Joseph, you write so much, IGNORE so many scriptures and the problems created by your narratives, a short comment is insufficient. But it’s your website to say whatever it is that you want to say/teach, truth or not. Just know my brother that Yehovah is going to judge your teachings! If you cannot answer tough questions; if you ignore scriptures, then understand, in all probability you may be teaching a wrong doctrine.

    You started your Newsletter with, “If Yeshua did not keep Passover the night before he died,…” THAT IS AN ASSUMPTION ON YOUR PART, NOT WHAT YESHUA SAID! But HE DID keep Passover that night in which He was betrayed!

    You are working on an ASSUMPTION that Yeshua, as God in the flesh, DID NOT KNOW as much as the sinful Jews did, as concerning “when” to observe Passover. BEWARE, my brother, YOU ARE JUDGING GOD! Yeshua KNEW TRUTH, even if the sinful Jews didn’t! Rom 3:4. “… let God be true though every man a liar!” You are teaching that God did not know when to observe His own commanded day? But the Jews did? Don’t you see the problem here? Yeshua/Jesus referred to this last meal as Passover on several occasions, so it was Passover! No matter what other verses or authors write, to conlude differently is to conclude God is wrong, mistaken, or a liar! Yeshua’s words are GOLD while all of our’s are but filthy rags! He is King, Master, Creator and you have the audacity to oppose or challenge His Words?

    Why did Judas and the Hign Priest do business on the high Holy Day? They didn’t! They did business on the evening portion of the 14th, in the evening hours after the 13th ended. The High Holy Day did not occur until sunset beginning the 15th! Do an e-Sword search for the words, “holy” & “Passover.” They do not appear together in KJ, MKJV, LITV (literal translation by Professor Jay Green,) YLT (Youngs Literal Translation, etc…, except in 2 Chr 35:13, where Passover is not referred to as “holt” but that they ROASTED the lamb while sodding Holy offerings in pots.) Passover is not a holy day because Yehovah DID NOT declare Passover as a HOLY DAY! (But He did the 15th)

    You have begun on a faulty foundation, ASSUMMING that Passover and Unleavened Bread are the SAME DAY! NOT SO! Passover occurred about midnight on night of the 14th, and the Feast of ULB is on the 15th! TWO SEPARATE EVENTS! TWO SEPARATE DAYS! The lambs blood had to be on the doorposts BEFORE midnight, so the lamb HAD to be slain between sunset and actual darkness about 30-70 minutes ON THE EVENING PORTION OF THE 14th. The Feast of ULB occurs on the MORROW AFTER Passover. Want Proof? Joshua 5:10-12. Whether one wrongly counts the daylight hours of the 14th as “the morrow” after Passover, (keep in mind that God counts days evening to evening, sunset to sunset, darkness to darkness, so the daylight was still the 14th not the morrow;) or whether you correctly count sunset of the 15th as the start of “the morrow;” either way, the Feast of ULB, FOLLOWS Passover. NOT, as you teach, that ULV occurs and then the angel of death passed over at midnight, ~ 6 hours into ULV. You IGNORE TRUTH of scriptures, as did the Jews in creating their “traditions!” Num 33:3, also identifies/clarifies that the 15th is the morrow AFTER Passover.

    Your narrative poses questions you can’t answer, (likely because your narrative is anti-scriptural, but based upon sinful Jewish traditions;) so you IGNORE the scriptures and questions your narrative raises. Being unable to answer questions SHOULD strike a chord warning you there could be a problem with what you are teaching. We should not “assume” we are always right! That’s not humility as Yehovah seeks, but personal ego.

    Consider this. IF the lamb is killed ~ 3pm, where is the hanging/bleed out/cooking time BEFORE the Feast of ULB began just a few hours later? If they cooked the lamb even for a minute after sunset, were they not working on the High Day Sabbath? And what about the fire? Ex 35:3 “kindle no fire on the Sabbath.” (includes High Sabbaths as well.) Feeding the fire would have been work too. Though you say the lamb can cook in 3-5 hours, I challenge you to cook a whole 30-40# lamb – head, entrails and all, where NONE of it is raw, in just 3-5 hours. It wouldn’t be fir to eat. Burned to a crisp on the outside and raw in the entrails. This coming from someone who has cooked for 60 years!

    I once roasted a gutted, thawed turkey on a spit in the fireplace for Thanksgiving one year. Three to three and a half hours in the fireplace. It was browned well on the outside, almost burned, and the dark meat was still too raw, and in the middle, to eat. A lamb weighs twice what a turkey does and the Passover still had head and entrails to cook too. 3-5 hours is far too insufficient a cooking time. Just shows your lack of culinary talents.

    And since anything left til morning was to be burned with fire, how could Israel have burned the leftovers on the morning of the 15th a high Holy Day? Especially when if they left the night of the 15th , they would not have been there to burn the leftovers.

    Not to mention Israel was not to leave their house til morning on the night of the actual Passing Over. Ex 12:22. So “how” could they have left in the night on the 15th without breaking this command? (that is, If Passover occurred on the 15th as you teach.) You ignore God’s TRUTH and commands because you start with the wrong foundation. If one starts a math equation believing that 1+1 = 3, is their math apt to ever be correct? Doubtful.

    I understand how you arrived at “between the evenings.” And I DO NOT DOUBT that Jewish “traditions” had developed in that fashion through the centuries, and was recorded as you quoted. BUT, by your narrative, the lamb was killed on the daytime hours of the 14th, NOT in the evening as God counts days in Gen 1. Then, by your narrative, Passover occurred on the next day/night because evening of the 15th had begun shortly after the lamb was killed at sunset? This is not eating on the “selfsame” day. You/the Jews have made Passover a literal 2 day affair by the way Yehovah counts time in Gen 1!

    The ONLY truths about the ORIGINAL Passover HAVE to come from those who experienced it, Moses and Joshua, (and Yeshua Messiah of course.) All other writings of men, including Josephus, one has to consider the false practices and changes introduced through the centuries.

    This has EVERYTHING to do with last week’s Midrash, “ears to hear/eyes to see.” (What the Spirit teaches!)

    I have no PROOF as to WHEN Yehovah made the decision, likely at the golden calf incident at Sinai, but after humbling the nation of Israel with slavery for 400 years, after them seeing the mighty plagues released on Egypt, the death of the Egyptian firstborn, after being led and protected by the cloud and pillar of fire, after seeing the Red Sea parted for them to escape, while God then got glory over the mighty Egyptian army, after eating manna supplied 6 days a week by Yehovah, after hearing His Magnificent voice thundering from atop Mt. Sinai, it took only 40 days of Moses being gone for them to rebel and make a golden calf, to the point where Yehovah was ready to annihilate them all. I don’t “know” but I would imagine that it could have been at this point also when Yehovah decided He would turn His face from them some time in the future to see what became of them, as in His Words, they were children in whom there WAS NO FAITH! Read Deu 32:20

    In this time period of decisions, He also revealed to Moses, that He had not given Israel eyes to see or ears to hear. Deu 29:4.

    Later in Isa 6:9-10 He basically sends the same curse that blinds the people from seeing, hearing, and understanding with their heart, BECAUSE THEY REFUSE TO BELIEVE AND OBEY this All Powerful, most Glorious, most Magnificent, Holy, Righteous Being Yehovah.

    Messiah references these verses of Isa 6:9-10 in Mat 13:14-15, and in the previous verse (13:13,) He states that this was the VERY REASON He spoke in parables, so that seeing they did not see, and hearing they did not hear. Yeshua/Yehovah DID NOT intend for the general populace to understand in Moses’ day, in Yeshua’s day, NOR even today! GRASP THAT! Such is WHY we have so many false preacher/teachers with so many opinions BECAUSE they DO NOT UNDERSTAND His truth, His Ways, and thoughts EITHER! Isa 55:8-9 They may “think” they know God, but they don’t. We are told in scripture not only “how” to live righteously, how to treat our fellow neighbor, but also what we are to believe, as taught by the Holy Spirit, NOT other men! Jn 6:45, Isa 54:13, Jn 16:13, 14:26. Men are trying to usurp the position of the Holy Spirit, take His job per se, by telling others what we are to believe!

    How many of us listen to, depend SOLELY upon the Holy Spirit of God to guide us into all truth? Or do we listen to the Grahams, the Swaggarts, the Stanleys, the Armstrong’s, the Dumonds, other commentators, authors, preachers and rabbis? WHO is listening to what the Holy Spirit of God teaches (which is scriptural,) while REJECTING the teachings/doctrines of their fellow men? It is THOSE listening to the Spirit that God gives eyes to see, ears to hear, and a heart/mind to understand Him and His TRUTHS! The blinding of the minds, the vail or covering comes from Him, ONLY HE can remove it so that we have eyes to see and ears to hear WHAT THE SPIRIT TEACHES. But because Israel made the golden calf, thus rejecting Yehovah, because Israel rejected Yehovah as their King in Samuel’s day, 1 Sam 8:7, 10:19; because the Jews rejected Yeshua as their Messiah ~2,000 years ago, that vail has remained over their minds so that they cannot have eyes to see, ears to hear, or a mind/heart to understand.

    And I fear for you my brother because ONLY in Yeshua Messiah is that vail lifted. 2 Cor 3:15-16. Since you dig in youe heels, continually seeking to challenge Messiah’s God given Passover/authority, because you want to teach that God in the flesh was wrong, mistaken, or a liar, I cannot help but wonder if your vail still remains. Because you cannot answer simple reasonable questions concerning your teachings, because you cannot explain how, according to your calendar, each of the six days leading up to the millenium, only have 980 years instead of 1,000 years each; because you cannot explain why the first Sabbatical cycle after a Jubilee is not 7 years by your teaching but 6. Because you cannot explain where the other 120 years are from the end of your calendars, 120 jubilees x 49 = 5880 years to the milennium, where are the other 120 years to 6,000? And to think all this calendar work is null and void simply because you started with the wrong premise, that jubilee cycles were every 49, instead of 50 years as scriptures teach. There are far too many questions you cannot answer concerning your “insights.” Therefore, it appears your vail remains, without eyes to see or ears to hear WHAT THE HOLY SPIRIT TEACHES! (not necessarily simply seeing “patterns,” like in Jewish mysticism and numerology.)

    But having not yet read the newsletter, I’m afraid my brother that you have started off on the wrong foundation. You seem to believe the teachings of men, (Jews,) rather than the Words of Yeshua Yehovah. When we go around stating that God in the flesh, Yeshua/Jesus, did not observe the Passover based upon man’s definition of the Greek word “artos,” disputing whether He recognized Passover as He said He was, then we/you seem to have a problem with believing God and God’s Word. Yeshua’s words OVERRULE anything and everything, other men say, write, or record.

    And it’s “possible” you can’t change your mind or understanding. In 2 Thess 2, GOD sends a strong delusion to make people believe what is false, especially those that believe lawless liars such as Trump. In Jn 12:40, Romans 11:7. He has blinded people’s eyes, hardened their hearts, so people could not understand, then or now. 2 Cor 13:13-16 He has placed a vail, a covering over people’s minds. Though taken away when one believes INTO Yeshua. If we call Him a liar and say that He didn’t observe Passover when that is exactly what He referred to the Last supper as, THEN WE ARE NOT IN (INTO) Messiah yet! We can’t say or believe He is mistaken or a liar and be in His good graces.

    But the nice thing about this vail that is over most everybody’s minds. Yehovah removes it in Isa 25:7.

    Now I guess I can read your newsletter now as I have addressed your “foreword.” Passover and Unleavened Bread are TWO separate occasions on TWO separate days, according to Yehovah’s Words to Moshe and Joshua. The Jews with their traditions have muddied the waters of understanding Yehovah’s TRUTH! That, and every man’s desire to believe what they want to believe, then seek scriptures to twist in an effort to justify their behaviors and conclusions. Read Gen chapter 1.

    There was darkness over the face of the deep. Darkness preceded the light. The darkness is called night or evening, the light is the waking, sunlit hours of the day. BUT together they make a DAY. There was evening (darkness/night) and there was morning (light/day) but together they made a day. Yehovah makes a clear distinction between evening and morning that the eye can see.

    Your “between the evenings” definitions muddies this distinction of Yehovah God, as the Jews evidently got to the point where THEY DECIDED the waning hours of the day, in the hours towards the going down of the sun, were part of the evening. That iS NOT what Gen 1 teaches! That is a bastardized Jewish concept, NOT what Yehovah teaches.

    And by the way, it was not intended to be a morning sacrifice and a late afternoon sacrifice on the same lighted day. It was SUPPOSED to be an EVENING sacrifice as night began the day, followed by a morning sacrifice as daylight hours began the lit day. In a continual burnt offering system it would be easy to blend the two together somewhat, consider man’s method of counting time, to where one might decide the morning sacrifice was first, starting the day. WRONG! The evening (night) sacrifice started the day and was FIRST, followed by the morning sacrifice (second.) To know TRUTH we have to acknowledge and observe Yehovah’s Ways and teachings, NOT man’s!

    Reply
    • Amazing how much you have to say having not read the newsletter by your own admission. Sad actually.

      Reply
      • I had that much to say based just upon your opening statements. LOL

        Reply
    • Hello J.W. Brakebill Jr,

      Isn’t it said that a kingdom that is divided won’t last? I think ther eis a lot to say about Gods word and there is a lot off mis information in the churches. But the biggest questions is how do we deal with it and discuss the matters at hand and dont go and throw mudd at eachother.

      How can you explain simply that Yeshua died as our Passover lamb ( in the afternoon before the sun got down when the lambs are supposed to be slaughtered) and did already eat this same meal the night before?

      And another thing that I read in your comments, when you count from the waving off the sheaf or the Omer of barley for 7 weeks you start on the first day (Sunday) of the week and count 49 days, the day after this day is day 50 right?
      But if you look at which day op the week that day is it is also the first day of that week! You don’t add a day o start the next week, this is exactly the same with counting the sabbatical years and the jubilee years. Pleas do the research for yourself.

      I don’t want to offend you but please. Remember what is written in Matthew 5:
      21 Ye have heard that it was said by them of old time, Thou shalt not kill; and whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment: 22but I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.

      Be careful what you say and which words you use.

      Reply
  10. I made a couple minor typo errors, but one MAJOR. I wrote 2 Cor 13:13-16 when it is 2 Cor 3, not 13.

    Reply
  11. Gee, what a group of nice guys! I am somewhat disappointed though. Are there no threats of the lake of fire or warnings of Yeshua saying “I never knew you” (perhaps the most terrifying and soul crushing words in all of scripture)?

    I’m certainly no teacher, but it appears to me that the word Passover is rather broadly used. Luke 22:1 refers to the “Feast of Unleavened Bread, which is called the Passover.” But Luke 22:7 refers to the Day of the Passover, speaking of Nisan 14, when the Passover sacrifice occurred. Yeshua instructed the disciples to prepare the Passover, which no doubt meant (in part) procuring the lamb and then getting it to the upper room, washing it, grooming it, feeding it- preparing it for sacrifice in the daylight of the 14th. John 19:14 states that it was “the day of preparation for the Passover”. The lamb itself was even sometimes referred to as “the Passover”‘.

    Do we think that the disciples had time to get, inspect, prepare, feed, sacrifice and roast a lamb on the evening (Tuesday night) of the 14th? (For the sake of argument, maybe Yeshua had simply told them a lamb wasn’t going to be necessary for the new, correct Passover dinner.)

    On the night of the supper in the upper chamber, Yeshua did say that he earnestly desired to eat this Passover with the guys, but then added “I will by no means eat it until it is fulfilled in the kingdom the Almighty.” (Luke 22: 15-16).

    As to those pesky Jews, John 2:13 tells us “And the Passover of the Jews was near and Yeshua went up to Jerusalem.”
    John 6:4 states, “Now the Passover, the feast of the Jews, was at hand.”John 11:55 also references the Passover of the Jews. There’s no mention of a false or incorrect Passover. An oversight, perhaps. Maybe it was just a reference point that Yeshua used in order to correct them there pesky Jews. I don’t know.

    So Joe threatens me that if I don’t observe Passover when he and Randy say the barley is ready, the Lord will say “I never knew you”. But Bob and J.W. say Joe is an arrogant quack. It can be very discouraging for half-wits like myself.

    Reply
    • I don’t think Joe is an arrogant quack. I just feel he has gonads the size of Mt. Everest or foolishness as deep as the ocean. LoL

      I tend to believe Yeshua, as God in the flesh, knew EXACTLY when to observe Passover whether the sinful pesky Jews did, or not. And I feel he is foolish for saying Messiah (God) didn’t know TRUTH.

      But Joe is well meaning, even if I don’t agree with him.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.